Vet Explains How to Help a Traumatized Shelter Cat Learn to Trust You

Cats that have experienced neglect, abandonment or long shelter stays may not immediately show affection after being adopted-not because they don’t want to-but because they’re learning to trust again.

That is the case for Mr. Wobbles, a 1-year-old black and white cat, currently searching for a home through June’s Senior Cat Rescue in New Mexico. After his previous owner reportedly moved away and left him outside with a deformed leg, rescuers stepped in when they saw a video of him dragging the injured limb.

Following an amputation and recovery, the rescue says Mr. Wobbles is ready for a new chapter, though he may need patience as he learns to feel safe.

"He has been through a lot and may need time to trust," the rescue wrote on Facebook, adding that once he feels comfortable, he becomes affectionate, enjoys sitting in laps and gets along well with other cats.

His story highlights a challenge many adopters face when bringing home a rescue cat with a difficult past. Dr. Tom Vega, DVM ambassador at Roo and founder and chief medical officer of Concierge Companions Vet Med, spoke with Newsweek about the ways to gain a shelter cat’s trust.

Vega said the biggest gift adopters can give a newly rescued cat is predictability. “Cats that have experienced neglect or trauma need time to learn that their new environment is safe and that their needs will be met consistently,” he said.

When bringing home a cat with an unknown history, Vega recommends, start small rather than immediately giving them access to the entire house.

A quiet room with essentials-including food, water, a litter box, scratching surfaces, hiding spots and elevated perches-can help a cat decompress while they adjust.

How Can You Tell If a Shelter Cat Is Scared?

Fear doesn’t always look the way people expect. While some cats flatten their ears, crouch low, refuse food or become defensive when approached, others simply withdraw. “Some cats appear shut down rather than aggressive, which can easily be mistaken for calm behavior,” Vega said.

However, the first signs that a cat is beginning to trust their new family are often subtle. A cat may begin eating while their owner is nearby, groom, stretch, blink slowly or explore while someone is in the room or sleep outside their hiding place.

Eventually, Vega said, they may begin approaching voluntarily, rubbing against their owners or furniture, and engaging in play.

Biggest Mistake New Adopters Make

Many adopters naturally want to shower a rescue with affection, but moving too quickly can overwhelm a frightened feline.

“The most common mistake adopters can make when trying to bond with a traumatized rescue cat is trying too hard, too quickly,” Vega said.

Avoid pulling a cat from its hiding place, forcing physical contact, introducing lots of visitors too soon or expecting immediate affection.

Instead, Vega recommends, let the cat choose when interactions happen and reward those moments of bravery with treats, interactive toys and calm praise. “Punishment should never be used for fear-based behaviors,” he said.

What About Tripod Cats?

Mr. Wobbles isn’t just recovering emotionally: He’s also adjusting to life on three legs.

The rescue also highlighted Winston, a 4-month-old kitten born without a foot who later underwent an amputation. Despite the surgery, Winston remains playful and is learning to navigate the world as a tripod cat.

While their histories are different, Vega said both cats illustrate how resilient tripod cats can be. “Most tripod cats adapt remarkably well, but they need a home that's easy to navigate while they rebuild strength and confidence.”

Early adjustments may include providing non-slip flooring, making food, water and litter boxes easy to reach and avoiding situations that force excessive jumping or climbing.

Owners should also monitor their cat's weight because carrying extra pounds can put additional stress on the remaining limbs.

“Most importantly, don’t underestimate them,” Vega said.

How Long Does It Take a Shelter Cat to Trust You?

Every rescue cat adjusts differently. Some begin relaxing within days, while others need weeks or even months before they feel completely comfortable.

Many adopters are familiar with the “3-3-3 rule“-three days to decompress, three weeks to establish routines and three months to fully settle in-but Vega said it should be viewed only as a guideline rather than a deadline.

If a newly adopted cat refuses food for more than 24 hours, stops drinking, isn’t using the litter box appropriately or shows persistent fear, aggression or self-injury, owners should contact their veterinarian.

“Medical problems can mimic behavioral concerns,” Vega said, “so a veterinary evaluation should always come first before assuming the issue is purely behavioral.”

For cats like Mr. Wobbles, trust isn’t built overnight. But with patience, predictable routines and the freedom to move at their own pace, even cats that have experienced neglect or trauma can learn that their new home is a safe one.

2026 NEWSWEEK DIGITAL LLC.

This story was originally published July 14, 2026 at 6:30 AM.