Both sides made their case Monday during an appeal filed by former Bibb County sheriffs deputy Clayton Sutton.
Sutton was fired last month for alleged insubordination.
The hearing was closed to the public at Suttons request. Such administrative hearings are generally open to the public, but Bibb Countys civil service guidelines give an employee the option to close it, and Sutton did so.
Hearing officer Joel Howe now has 15 days to rule on Suttons appeal, Macon-Bibb County spokesman Chris Floore said. However, Howe can request an additional 15 days if he deems it necessary.
Sutton was fired last month for disobeying an order by Sheriff David Davis. Davis had ordered Sutton to handle administrative work only while investigators checked an incident in which Sutton fired his weapon at a dog while chasing a suspect.
Davis later said Sutton disobeyed the order after he stopped people on Ga. 247 for acting suspiciously.
Sutton gained notoriety in December 2012 while he was a member of the Macon Police Department after he shot and killed Sammie Junebug Davis Jr. in the parking lot of a Pio Nono Avenue grocery store after Davis attacked him.
The incident sparked several protests in Macon by residents who wanted Sutton fired. A GBI investigation cleared Sutton, however, calling the shooting justified.
To contact writer Phillip Ramati, call 744-4334.