SEC will continue its roll with nation’s best players

January 23, 2013 

Nick Saban might not be the best coach in college football, but he’s certainly one of the smartest. And most prescient.

His first two head coaching jobs were in the North: at Toledo (in 1990) and at Michigan State (1995-99). At East Lansing, he compiled a record of 34-24-1 during his tenure. That’s hardly Coaching Pantheon territory, especially considering he lost each of three bowl games.

But Saban did go 9-2 in his final season with Sparty. When LSU came calling with a coaching offer in December of 1999, Saban jumped at it. Why? Well, in addition to the fact LSU doubled his salary, Saban understood two simple facts. First: good players make good coaches. Also: good players live in the South.

Now at Alabama, Saban’s Crimson Tide recently won its third BCS championship in four years. It was the seventh straight title for the SEC. Good players also make good conferences.

Almost half (46) of ESPN’s top 100 football recruiting class for 2013 hail from states with traditional SEC affiliations. Throw in the 13 from Texas now that A&M and Missouri are part of the mix, and it’s clear the best football prospects in the nation are SEC born and bred.

And not only are the best players from SEC territory, they play college ball at SEC schools. Based on the same ESPN data, recruiting classes from 2009 through 2012 produced 185 Top 100 prospects from the Deep South. Almost 2/3 of them (65 percent) signed with SEC schools. And that doesn’t factor in those top prospects from outside the South who choose to play their ball here.

Obviously, not all recruits pan out. In addition, less regarded prospects sometimes develop into superstars. (Heisman Award winner Johnny Manziel of Texas A&M was not on the ESPN list.). But in college football, depth of talent is the single biggest factor in a program’s success.

Why are southern football players better? They aren’t necessarily better athletes, but they are better trained for their craft. The high school coaching they receive is top-notch because their communities demand quality football. In addition, the passionate Friday Night environment prepares them for Saturday afternoons.

Northern kids are just as tough. But they’re in the gym playing basketball five months out of the year. If and when spring breaks, they’re desperate to get outside and throw the baseball around from late April and into August. In other words, football is a seasonal activity. In the South, as we all know, it’s a way of life.

College football’s four-team playoff will only solidify the SEC’s dominance when it begins with the end of the 2014 regular season. A national semifinal round that doesn’t include at least two SEC teams will be a rare one.

How can the rest of the schools in the country compete? They won’t if they rely on high school recruiting to build their programs. Their best option is to exploit the junior college talent market. Those kids are seasoned and hungry.

Until that happens, brace yourself for more of the same. SEC! SEC!

Contact Chris Deighan at

The Telegraph is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service