NFL and its referees should end the travesty this season is becoming

September 26, 2012 

Rarely do we comment on sports related issues on these pages, but the ending of the Seattle Seahawks Green Bay Packers game on Monday night is worth comment. If National Football League leaders didn’t know it already, they should know it now. The replacement referees, standing in for real NFL refs who have been locked out by the league, aren’t working. They are doing the best job their experience allows, but that’s not good enough.

Monday night on a last second “Hail Mary” pass that appeared to have been intercepted by Green Bay, giving them the game was called a catch by the Seahawks and victory was theirs. One official at the scene called time because the catch in the end zone would have been a touchback, while another, standing just feet apart signaled touchdown. Instant replay did not give enough conclusive evidence to reverse the call. However, for the fans who stayed up late enough to watch the game’s finish, there was evidence aplenty.

That wasn’t all. In other games over the weekend, the replacement refs had other issues from the placement of the ball to calling a field goal good or not. The replacement refs are inconsistent, at best, at how they call games and this has led to numerous shoving matches between players.

The biggest issue is over the refs’ defined benefit retirement plan. The league would like to change that to a defined contribution plan. Here’s a compromise that might work. We are sure the highly-paid lawyers on both sides of this issue have already thought about it. For the present refs, let them stay on their defined benefit plan, but new refs would go to a 401k type plan. That’s how many governments and companies have handled the issue. This could work for the NFL as well.

-- The Editorial Board

The Telegraph is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service